What Is the Average Home Price in Popular Winter Garden, Florida Neighborhoods?

Winter Garden continues to be one of Central Florida’s most sought-after places to live, and home prices reflect that demand. The city offers a wide range of neighborhoods, from historic districts near downtown to newer master-planned communities in Horizon West. While prices fluctuate with the market, most buyers should expect Winter Garden home values to land higher than many surrounding cities.

As of recent market activity, the overall average home price in Winter Garden typically falls in the mid-$500,000s, with some neighborhoods slightly below or well above that range depending on age, location, and amenities.

Here’s a general snapshot of pricing in some of the most popular Winter Garden areas:

Popular Winter Garden Neighborhoods and Average Prices
• Downtown Winter Garden: $500,000–$650,000
Historic charm, walkability, and limited inventory often push prices higher for renovated or well-located homes.

• Horizon West (overall): $550,000–$650,000
Newer construction, community amenities, and strong school zoning drive demand across multiple communities. This area is still growing with newly constructed roads coming soon.

• Independence: $575,000–$700,000
Known for trails, lakes, community events, and proximity to Disney-area employment.

• Summerlake: $550,000–$650,000
Master-planned feel with newer homes, parks, and access to shopping and dining.

• Stoneybrook West: $500,000–$600,000
Golf course community with established homes and a range of sizes and price points.

• Oakland / West Winter Garden: $450,000–$750,000
Older homes are often slightly more affordable while still offering proximity to the West Orange Trail and downtown areas. However, newer communities boast luxurious homes in gated or private communities.

What Drives These Price Differences
Several factors influence pricing across Winter Garden neighborhoods:
• Age of construction and home condition
• Lot size and water or golf course views
• Community amenities and HOA structure
• School zones and commute access
• Walkability to downtown or trails

Even within the same neighborhood, prices can vary widely based on upgrades, layout, and recent comparable sales.

Bottom Line:
Winter Garden offers diverse housing options, with average home prices generally ranging from the high-$400,000s to well over $700,000 in premium communities. The right value depends on location, lifestyle preferences, and timing in the market.

If you’re considering a move to Winter Garden and want a realistic, up-to-date view of pricing by neighborhood, visit NextHomeEric.com. I’ll help you compare areas, review recent sales, and find the home that fits both your lifestyle and your budget.